Tech · Explainer

SpaceX Catches Starship. Vulcan Loses 40 Amazon Satellites

SpaceX brought its upper stage home after deploying 26 Starlink satellites. A day later, United Launch Alliance lost the largest batch Amazon Leo had tried to launch.

Starship hangs in the launch tower’s arms while an engineer holds a satellite model beside a diagram of a missing satellite.
AI-generated illustration: Kunkafa

Kunkafa News · Published · 2 min read

Kareem FaridBy Discuss with the author on X

Key points

  • Starship’s upper stage made its first return from orbit to the launch tower. The Super Heavy booster was lost on the same flight.
  • Amazon had booked 38 Vulcan launches. The failure came on the first of them.

On Saturday, November 14, SpaceX caught a spacecraft roughly the height of a 20-story building as it returned from orbit to its launch tower in Texas. On Sunday, a United Launch Alliance rocket lifted off from Florida carrying 40 internet satellites for Amazon. None reached orbit [1] [2] [3].

Vulcan lifted off at 17:40 UTC on November 15. ULA said something went wrong about ten minutes into the flight and opened an investigation. The company had yet to identify the cause publicly. Spaceflight Now described it as the first total mission failure for the Boeing–Lockheed Martin joint venture since its formation in 2006 [2].

Before its return to Texas, Starship deployed 26 satellites for SpaceX’s own Starlink network. Some 22 hours after liftoff, the tower caught the upper stage. The Super Heavy booster had already been lost on its return. Flying that same upper stage again would be the next proof of reuse [1].

When does reuse pay off?

Amazon’s bet was on the size of each delivery. It contracted for 38 Vulcan launches to carry more than 1,500 first-generation Leo satellites. A shorter upper stage made room for more satellites, and the first flight carried six side boosters. A single launch could spread its cost over 40 spacecraft. Losing that flight also meant losing the whole batch at once [3] [4].

SpaceX wants to spread another large expense, the cost of building the rocket, across many flights. Its June prospectus lists a design capacity of more than 100 metric tons to low Earth orbit for Starship. The next flights could show how much cargo the recovered ship can carry and how much work it needs between launches [1] [5].

A returning stage carries a heat shield and reserves fuel for the trip home. On a given rocket, each kilogram reserved for the return reduces the weight available for cargo. As researchers at NASA Langley and Georgia Tech explain, reuse can save money when a vehicle flies enough times and the cost of getting it ready again stays low. The measure that counts for a satellite operator is the cost per kilogram actually delivered to the intended orbit [6].

Amazon has another route to orbit while ULA investigates. It is targeting November 23 at the earliest for an Ariane 6 launch carrying 36 more Leo satellites [3].

Sources: [1] Associated Press, Nov. 14 · [2] Spaceflight Now, Nov. 15 · [3] Amazon mission updates, Nov. 15 · [4] Amazon, Nov. 9 · [5] SpaceX prospectus, June 5 · [6] NASA Langley and Georgia Tech, 2022.

Kunkafa forecasts

SpaceX

How far it could move, which way, by when, and how confident Kunkafa is.

Check the latest forecasts

More in Tech

From the Blog

All articles